ALL-IN ON BOOK REVIEWS: Do you have a (non-fictional or fictional) book related to wine, spirits, or beer that you'd like reviewed? Contact me!

Sunday, May 10, 2015

In defense of the CSW (Certified Specialist of Wine)

Society of Wine Educators CSW (Certified Specialist of Wine)

There are many that feel that being certified in wine knowledge is a load of bull. Then there are those that are certified that believe the CSW is a joke. I'm going to explain to you why neither case is true.

You don't need a certification to have a superior knowledge of wine or to be in the business. Kevin Zraly is certified in squat and that guy is a hero in the wine industry. But you do need to gain the education, and certifications provide you with the tools to get it. That is the key to the value of wine certification. It's not just the letters after your name. It's not to show "look what I can do, look how special I am" although that's fun too. It's about what you learned along the way. Even if you fail or never take the actual test, the education is invaluable.

One exception to that rule might be the Master Sommelier. These guys already know everything they need to know to make some impressive coin in the industry. But they still sacrifice years and even decades of their lives obsessing every minute of every day over appellations and rules and smells and vintages to earn that certification, often failing year after year. Many Advanced Sommeliers don't even try to get it because they'd like to see their family and keep their marriage intact. It's the hardest test in the world, regardless of the topic, and the drive is the title. And who could blame them? It's an enormously impressive accomplishment to be one of only 219 Master Sommelier's in the world. I'm completely jealous of their knowledge and admire their ambition.

But you know what? It's totally cool that I'm a Certified Specialist of Wine. What's even way cooler is that I can tell a customer that Franciacorta can't start its lees aging until February if that pops up in a conversation. Could I have learned that on my own? Sure. Would I remember that if I didn't have to memorize a whole book to pass a test? Hell no. That's a piece of info you might decide isn't important unless it could be the difference between passing and failing.

Society of Wine Educators' Certified Specialist of Wine pin
Yes, I just said that I'm a CSW. A proud one. But what is that? It's a certification awarded by the Society of Wine Educators for passing a rigorous test designed for those with a vast knowledge of wine. Remember that underlined part. It's the first of two levels that the SWE offers for wine, but it's about the equivalent of the mid-level in other certification organizations with various tiers. In my opinion it's the ideal education for those in the retail and distribution end of the business, as it focuses solely on academic knowledge / theory.

A sommelier on the other hand is somebody that serves wine, so naturally the various sommelier certification organizations and tiers are the ideal educational route for those in the restaurant business. They include the service and tasting portions needed for being, ya know, an actual sommelier. There's about a 0.1% chance that I will ever work in the restaurant industry so why the heck would I want a distraction into that stuff? Cram my brain full of the information I need to know to better serve my customers, please.

So now on with the point of this article: CSW is scoffed at by some of those in the other certification systems when used as a post-nominal. I'm fully convinced it's simply because of the name, its American headquarters and time spent on the test. Certified Specialist of Wine doesn't sound fancy like Sommelier. It's not internationally recognized like WSET. It takes one hour to take the actual test and I don't have to fly to Florida. So it must be a knock-off wannabe certification, right?

Wrong. That test is no joke.

You have one hour to answer a hundred questions that could come from anywhere in the 300 page study guide. And I mean anywhere. The top 5 red grapes of Austria, how long the minimum leese contact is for Gran Reserva Cava, the difference between Guyot and Cordon pruning, Santa-this is within Santa-that in the Central Coast, the year the French settled in Franschhoek, yadda yadda yadda. And you don't learn these things in a tier system. There's one test for, as I stated earlier, a vast knowledge of wine. So that book must be memorized as much as you can possibly handle because you have absolutely no idea what you will be expected to know. The one I took was pretty heavy with New Zealand questions. And by heavy, I mean three.

Over half of the people that think they're ready to pass the CSW will walk out failing a multiple-choice test.

I HATE TESTS!You need to get 75% right to pass, more than the other certifications considered to be on the same level, and there's only a 45% pass rate, much less than the others. That's right: Over half of the people that think they're ready to pass the CSW will walk out failing a multiple-choice test. That includes many that are already certified elsewhere.

The CSW is also an earn-on-the-job requirement for certain positions in alcohol distribution companies, and some of those employees were just promoted from being a merchandiser. Chances are what they know about wine is pretty minimal, and even after plenty of time studying they're almost guaranteed to fail on the first try... just like the majority of people on their first try. Which is also why those companies give you multiple chances. Some even offer unlimited. Which is nuts. But it also speaks to how valuable the study is, and they're well aware of that. The more you know about your product the better you are at pushing it.

All in all, the low pass rate is probably because it's been self-taught (until now)There hasn't been anybody teaching a class that guides you through this and keeps your learning on a schedule, or a packet with a plan that comes in the mail like WSET or the first some-odd tiers of the Somm organizations. The teaching ability of an instructor and the visual / hands-on experience that kicks things off elsewhere is simply not a factor here. And an offseason where you can take a break from your studies? Pffft. Please.

There's just one book filled with anything you could possibly need to know about wine, and you have one year after signing up to take one test that covers it all. And you need to learn it all if you want to guarantee a passing grade, without any plan other than your own. It's always been entirely up to your abilities and your own determination and ambition, along with a realistic understanding of how you learn and retain information, to do this on your own time in your own home. 

King Leonidas, 300
Every certification requires tremendous dedication but the CSW, above all of the mid-level ones, practices nature over nurture. There's no send off into adulthood. You've metaphorically been thrown to the wolves from the very beginning like a prepubescent Leonidas. Thus, a person with a CSW post-nominal earned that title and nobody deserves any credit for it except for themselves. That alone deserves respect. And the material that you're required to study and know deserves as much respect as other certifications that are considered to be at a higher level. So the next time you see somebody with a CSW at the end of their name, see it as a well earned title instead of an undeserved chest-puffing.

Earlier I put until now in parentheses when I said the test is self-taught and that's because the Society of Wine Educators has just started offering online preparation classes to SWE members, which is totally awesome. But that's if you can get in because the classes get booked super-fast.

I worked incredibly hard to ace that CSW test with a score of 93 and you can actually read proof of that hard work in my article The CSW Experience (http://www.thewinestalker.net/2014/04/the-csw-experience.html). When I started studying I thought I had a good grasp of wine knowledge and it turned out that I knew nothing. So I'm grateful every day for the challenge the Society of Wine Educators gave me. I will be a loyal supporter of theirs until the day I die, and I'm going for the CSS (Certified Specialist of Spirits) in June or July before I start studying for the CWE (Certified Wine Educator). I also have every intention of becoming a paid member soon.

I'm extremely proud of my CSW effort and I tack those letters on at the end of my name at every opportunity... unless I'm being so foulmouthed that the Society would kick me out if I attach them to it. And I do swear. A lot. I'm surprised I've made it to the end of this article without dropping an F bomb. You should be proud of me for that, at the very least.

- Joey Casco, CSW
  TheWineStalker.net

Society of Wine Educators website: http://www.societyofwineeducators.org/
The SWE's blog "Wine, Wit and Wisdom": http://winewitandwisdomswe.com/
Online Prep Classes: http://winewitandwisdomswe.com/csw-online-review-class/
Newer Posts Older Posts Home

40 comments:

  1. Steve the Wine GeekMay 10, 2015 at 3:28 PM

    Congrats on your CSW! I worked hard for my CSW, and know that you did too! We should both be proud!

    ReplyDelete
  2. LOVE this post! Spotted it on Facebook, as someone I know in the biz posted it. It was perfect for me to share on my page (and I did) because I often have people ask me if my CSW means that I'm a Sommelier. Uh, no, it doesn't. LOL! So, I usually have to take a few minutes and explain the difference. Happily, a few friends DID read and comment. Whew! A few down…SO many more to go. But that's ok. It goes hand-in-hand with education (of wine AND of the certification).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Glad you enjoyed it, Amerilis! To be honest I thought I would get a lot of heat for this post but so far it's been a massive amount of support. Cheers! :)

      Delete
  3. This inadequacy of books to quicken spiritual growth is the reason why, although almost every one of us can speak most wonderfully on spiritual matters, fraud examination 5th edition

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Joey, I loved this article and I love your writing style. I'm in the wine industry, trying to decide what further education I want to pursue. WSET, CSW, etc. I found this article to be very helpful, thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I read Your article, and I would say that, Those students who are failing in test or in exams they can get help from UAE number 1 University Dissertation Help in Dubai at very reasonable cost, so students don't waste your time, visit our website now.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hey first of all I would like to congratulate you on your achievement. I have been an academic writer for more than a decade now, helping students have been my ultimate goal. Currently, I provide MBA Assignment Help Dubai. As I am residing in Dubai. I make sure that no one gets a bad grade that's the main reason I get into the writing industry.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Keep up the excellent piece of work, I read few blog posts on this web site and I conceive that your site is rattling interesting and contains circles of great info. 풀싸롱

    ReplyDelete
  8. If you’re looking Dj For Wedding we are the best choice we have our team is very representable with perfect attire and we have proper tools for everything we will make your event memorable with your loved ones you don’t have to waste your valuable money and on any other Dj because we are the and the wedding most important event in our life you don’t your guests to get bored In an wedding.

    ReplyDelete
  9. The company specializes in fabrics and mass production of urethane, plastics and rubber products. If you're looking for Support Belts For Elderly
    Many of our products are taken from raw materials to finished products using our proprietary manufacturing you can also have Hip Support.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Seaside Foot & Ankle offers a full range of the latest professional podiatry clinical treatments
    Neuroma Treatment and surgical solutions for people of all ages we have Advanced Foot And Ankle Clinic from children to seniors. Our Services include Flat Feet Treatment diagnostics and clinical treatment of common Foot And Ankle Care conditions, as well as surgery which can be performed at either a hospital facility or an outpatient surgical center.

    ReplyDelete
  11. At Reliable and Renewable Energy, we’re on a mission to enable everyone to get clean, affordable, and reliable energy from the sun.
    Long Description. We drive the transition to a sustainable, reliable and affordable energy. Our solar programs encompass a broad range of material sourcing and services.
    Solar Edge Minnesota

    ReplyDelete
  12. MWW, Inc. Roofing understands that purchasing a new roof is a big decision. We are here to supply you with all the information you need so you can make the best choice. Along with new installations, we also offer quick repair services for any roof.
    Roof Repair Cape Coral FL

    ReplyDelete
  13. Northeast Fireshield is a privately owned corporation, founded in 1989. We are the distributor and licensed applicators for Inspecta-Shield Plus™ a Class ‘A’ spray on penetrating fire retardant. The company has extensive experience in the fire retardant treatment of homes, commercial business including places of public assembly such as schools, colleges, restaurants, resorts, hotels, and airplane interiors. Inspecta-Shield Plus is non-toxic, odorless, colorless and provides a UV protectant. All treatments follow a strict quality control process and are performed by trained and certified applicators that will issue a Certificate of Flame proofing on completion.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Camp N Car makes easily installed camping products and runs a full service Van Conversion Companies custom shop to transform your vehicle into a comfortable and stylish camper anytime, anywhere. Whether you’re looking for Van Camping Gear to drop the lease and spend some time on the open road or just want an alternative to tent camping and expensive hotels, Camp N Car makes it easy and affordable.

      Delete
  14. Kratom Kings started on the idea that while kratom has become more accessible, the supply for lab tested, quality kratom is not fully developed and that by providing that to our customers they can save money and rest assured knowing that the product they are buying is safe and effective. We sell the finest herbal supplements on the Palouse at the best price! We guarantee to beat any price in the Palouse and surrounding areas. All of our products are lab tested for safety and potency and we have a much larger selection than anyone else in the area.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Decades of Sales experience. Successfully sold thousands of properties, Billions of dollars worth of Real Estate. Sales experience spanning decades. Thousands of homes worth billions of dollars were successfully sold. I am a Real Estate Broker with the skills and experience to take care of all of your Real Estate requirements. Allow me to usher you into your next chapter. As a desi agent, I take pleasure in offering exceptional service to both buyers and sellers. I make it a point to get to know each client’s individual needs, tastes, and style for looking for house or selling your Home. I use those insights, as well as extensive market data and personalized marketing plans, to assist customers in looking for house or selling your home for the highest potential price.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Reliable and Renewable Energy, we’re on a mission to enable everyone to get clean, affordable, and reliable energy from the sun. We drive the transition to a sustainable, reliable and affordable energy. Our solar programs encompass a broad range of material sourcing and services. We can help you fulfill your energy needs by providing the greatest quality product and service, whether you need solar electricity for your home, business, or farm. The increase in extreme weather events and rising sea levels are unmistakable signs of climate change. Roughly 850 million people still live without access to electricity, which is the foundation of sustainable development.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Are you tired of trying new ways to achieve the prosperity and freedom that you truly desire to only end up right back in the same place in which you started from? Timithy James personal development coach will provide you with a proven 12 step system that will guide you to achieving the abundance that you were intended to have. All your life’s aspirations are only a short journey away from your new reality.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Prinkey Consulting LLC is a Veteran owned company that focuses on crime prevention and liability mitigation. Crime prevention can be achieved by reducing the opportunities for criminal activity. The three strategies applied to accomplish this goal are Crime Prevention Through Environment Design, Threat and Vulnerability Assessment and a crime analysis.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Louis G. Friedman, President of Production Logistics, is a San Francisco native and cum laude graduate of the University of California. Mentored by Alfred Hitchcock’s Assistant Director at Universal Studios, he was a Production Supervisor for Lucasfilm Ltd. contributing to ‘More American Graffiti’, ‘The Empire Strikes Back’, ‘Return of the Jedi’, ‘Raiders of the Lost Ark’ and ‘Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom’. As a Production Executive he worked with Dutch Director Paul Verhoeven on cult classic ‘Starship Troopers’ and in Mexico with Director James Cameron on ground breaking ‘Titanic’, which grossed $2.2B worldwide. As an Executive Producer, films include Science Action Fantasy ‘Bloodshot’, Mark Wahlberg’s true Boston bombing story ‘Patriots Day’ and ‘Lone Survivor’ which earned nearly $200M worldwide box office. Additional film credits as Executive Producer include ‘American Wedding’, ‘American Reunion’, ‘Piranha 3D’, ‘Into the Blue’, ‘Blue Crush’, ‘How High’ and ‘Accepted’.

    ReplyDelete
  20. LADY DIVA'S CLOSET is an online shopping experience of all women's apparel and accessories for the modern and fashionable "diva" who wants to look her best. It is a specialty collection of bodycon dresses, off the shoulder/cold shoulder tops and dresses, sexy shoes, accessories and so much more.

    ReplyDelete
  21. at best prices is our mission. Our team is always ready with immediate solutions when students reach out to them asking for help with my assignment writing Best paper writing service Dubai

    ReplyDelete
  22. Congratulations on your certificación, I’m on my second chance to the text, I took it 4 years ago and today I know a bit more about wine but it’s still overwhelming… for example, no way in the book is the answer to the predominant white grape variety in E. Europe? How and where do I find the answer? What do you suggest?
    Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  23. Hello Students! I am Mark Xenny, and I am a professional Math Assignment Helper in Singapore. I have been assisting students with their math assignments for over five years now. My expertise lies in various areas of mathematics, including algebra, calculus, and statistics. I am passionate about helping students understand complex mathematical concepts and achieve academic success. If you need any assistance with your math assignments, feel free to reach out to me.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Are you searching for online Assignment Help UAE? From Assignment Help AUS. We offer you best assignment services in the most affordable price. Our Experts are provided you high quality assignments help and they are improved you’re writing skills. We are available 24*7 to assist you. If you want more detail, visit now and place your order now!

    ReplyDelete
  25. universal source of energy that can be observed in positively and negatively aspects that happens naturally in lightning or we can see in a generator and expresses itself in forms of electron motion and interaction" online Dissertation writing services

    ReplyDelete
  26. Do you want UAE Assignment Help Experts? Hire Assignment Help AUS Experts; we only provide plagiarism-free content. We are completing your assignment on time. We work only on quality assignments. Our assignment is so satisfying. We have professionals are well-educated and well-trained. We support 24x7 for all students. Visit-us.

    ReplyDelete
  27. if you have no bullying titles for an essay or do not know where to start. Generally, a bullying essay is no different from other academic tasks. What is more online dissertation help

    ReplyDelete
  28. Becoming a Certified Specialist of Wine signifies expertise in the world of wine. This esteemed certification acknowledges in-depth knowledge of wine regions, varietals, and production techniques. Holders demonstrate mastery in wine tasting, pairing, and evaluation. For enthusiasts and professionals alike, this certification is a testament to a profound understanding of the art and science of winemaking.

    ReplyDelete
  29. I admire this article for the well-researched content and excellent wording. I got so involved in this material that I couldn’t stop reading. I am impressed with your work and skill. Thank you so much online dissertation help

    ReplyDelete
  30. You mentioned in your previous post some tips for removing facial shadows which I have benefited a lot from using. I hope these tips will be useful for us too. Academic writers help

    ReplyDelete
  31. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  32. "The Wine Stalker" blog is likely a platform dedicated to exploring and reviewing various wines. With a focus on wine-related content, the blog may feature tasting notes, recommendations, and insights into the world of viticulture. Wine enthusiasts and connoisseurs may find valuable information and perspectives on different vintages and varietals on "The Wine Stalker" blog.
    henrico traffic lawyer
    virginia uncontested divorce
    virginia personal injury settlements
    uncontested divorce in va
    uncontested divorce in virginia

    ReplyDelete
  33. Your post covers each and every aspect or essential topics require for it. Love to read it. There are many ways to get rid of old cars. Your content is amazing. Please share more stuff regarding online dissertation help

    ReplyDelete
  34. Presenting awards to the hardworking people can encourage them to learn more and show their best. your award celebration party is fantastic and i really enjoyed the whole event description. Online dissertation writer UAE

    ReplyDelete
  35. Due to the natural surroundings of a selling atmosphere, most transactions roles include an excessive deal of compression though don’t use “stress conferences” to the extent this quality. Custom Dissertation Writing Services

    ReplyDelete
  36. Респіраторні ускладнення: серед ускладнень цього захворювання можна відзначити інфекції легенів, такі як ателектаз (застій легень) і апопексія (зменшення кількості кисню в крові).

    2. Очні ускладнення: також можуть виникнути такі ускладнення, як запалення та набряк рогівки, а в деяких випадках – постійні ускладнення, такі як втрата зору та сліпота.

    3. Мозкові ускладнення: це включає запалення головного мозку (енцефаліт) і запалення головного мозку (енцефаломієліт), які можуть мати серйозні наслідки для здоров'я.
    Докладніше про це

    ReplyDelete

Labels

*SPONSORED* ABriefHistoryOf Abruzzo Agiorgitiko Aglianico Airen Albarino Aleatico Alentejo Alexander Valley Alicante Bouschet Alsace Apothic Argentina Armagnac Arroyo Grande Arroyo Seco audio article Australia Austria Baco Barbera Barrossa Valley Batman Beaujolais beer Best Of biodynamic blend blog Bogati Bonarda book Bordeaux bourbon box wine Brachetto brandy Bulgaria Burgundy Cabernet Franc Cabernet Sauvignon Cahors Caino Blanco California Campania Canada Canaiolo. cans Cape Cod Captain America Carignan Cariñena Carmenere Catalonia Cava Central Coast certification Chablis Chalk Hill Champagne Chardonnay cheese Chenin Blanc Chianti Chile China cider Cinsault Clarksburg cocktails Cognac Colombard Columbia Valley comics Cotes-du-Rhone Counoise Croatia CSW Dane Cellars DC dessert wine Distill Wars Dona Blanco Douro Dry Creek Dunnigan Hills Edna Valley Falanghina February Felix Hart Fer Servadou Fiano fiction Finger Lakes Folle Blanche formulas France Franciacorta Frankovka Frappato Furmint Galicia Galilee Gamay Garganega Gascony Germany Gewurtztraminer gin Glera Godello Graciano greco di tufo Greece Grenache Grenache Blanc Grillo Gros Manseng Gruner Veltliner GSM guest blog Heroes history horror how to Hungary interview Israel Italy Japan Jerez Kansas kosher Lambrusco Languedoc-Roussillon Left Coast Leyda Valley Lisboa Livermore Lodi Loire Loureira love letter Macon Madeira Madiran Malbec Malvasia Marcillac marijuana Marlborough Marsanne Marselan Marvel Massachusetts Matchbook Mavrud Mazuelo McLaren Vale mead Melnik Mencia Mendocino Mendoza Meritage Merlot Mexico Michigan mixology Monbazillac Monstant Montecucco Montepulciano Monterey Montery Moscato Mosel Mourvédre Muscadelle Muscat mythology Napa Navarra Nebbiolo Nero d'Avola New York New Zealand news non-alcoholic nonfiction Norello Mascalese North Coast Oakville Oregon organic original meme pairings Palestine Pecorino Pedro Ximenez Perricone Petit Verdot Petite Sirah Petite Verdot photo gallery phylloxera Picpoul Piedmont Pinot Blanc Pinot Gris/Grigio Pinot Meunier Pinot Noir Pinotage Pliny podcast Port Portugal Press Release Primitivo product Prosecco Provence quickie quote rakia recipe retail problems Retsina review Rheingau Rhone Rias Baixas Ribera del Duero Riesling Rioja Rondinella rose Roussanne Rubin Rueda rum Russian River Sagrantino Sake Salta Sandanski Misket Sandeanski Misket Sangiovese Sangria santa clara Santa Lucia Higlands Sauvignon Blanc science scotch Sekt Semillon Seyval Blanc Sherry Sicily Somontano Sonoma South Africa South Australia Spain spark Sparkling Spider-Man spirits stemware storage study sulfites Superman sustainable SWE Syrah Tannat Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Temecula Tempranillo Tequila Texas thc The Flash Tinta Amarela Tinta Caiada Torrontes Touriga Nacional Traminer Trebbiano Trincadeira Turkey Tuscany Ugni Blanc Umbria USA Valdiguié Valiant Valpolicella vegan Veneto Verdejo Verdicchio Vermentino Vermont Vermouth Vernacca Vidal Blanc video Vinho Verde Viognier Virginia Viura vodka Walla Walla Washington State whiskey White zinfandel Wildstorm Willamette wine Wine Bloggers Off-Topic wine club Wine Pick Wolverine Wonder Woman Zinfandel Zweigelt