Tuesday, March 26, 2019

Are consumer wine reviews more accurate than expert reviews?

What is a wine expert to the vast majority of wine consumers? I’m talking about your Woodbridge, Barefoot, and Cavit drinkers. The people who would buy the “basic case” from my ‘Liquor stores should have “combo meals”’ blog post a few weeks ago. These people are incredibly important to the wine industry, but what does the opinion of a wine expert mean to them? Not much. 

They’re enjoying themselves drinking the wine that they like and they’re more likely to listen to a friend or another average wine consumer for suggestions than they are to even read a word of what Eric Asimov has to say.

Just a few nights ago I tasted a popular wine that I thought was so terrible that I dumped it down the sink, so I looked up what people said about it on Vivino. It has an average of 4 out of 5, and there are a hell of a lot of everyday people commenting on how much they like it. It actually shocked me. But really, that just speaks to the wine’s popularity. It appeals to the masses. Yet anybody in the business or who has developed their palate would dump it out like I did.

So does that make consumer reviews more accurate for average consumers than expert reviews? I actually think so. I used to not even pay attention to the average ratings on Vivino and Delectable but I’ve come to think of it as a valuable tool. Not for myself, but for gauging how the wine is perceived by the general public. 

More and more I see people walking around the shop using these wine review apps to check out their scores so they can make a purchase decision. I think that’s great. This technology is letting people explore and not be afraid of wine anymore, and what they’re seeing is an honest result of how people feel about that wine. It will only lead to more interest in wine, and in better wine. And us wine experts will be there to show them the good stuff.

What do you think?

Newer Posts Older Posts Home


  1. Is the Woodbridge/Barefoot/Cavit drinker the "average wine drinker"? I would identify them as a baseline - a sizable number of people without developed palates, but I would put the average further up the ladder - perhaps those who spend about $10 on a bottle. And you are right, the experts are pretty meaningless to those folks - expert advice probably kicks in around the $15 price point, where wines begin to have some individual characteristics and may actually vary from vintage to vintage.

    1. Great point, Jim! $12-13 for a 750 is the hot-spot for wine right now.



*SPONSORED* ABriefHistoryOf Agiorgitiko Aglianico Airen Albarino Aleatico Apothic Argentina Australia Austria Barbera beer Best Of biodynamic blend blog Bogati Bonarda book Bordeaux Brachetto brandy Bulgaria Cabernet Franc Cabernet Sauvignon California Campania Canada cans Cape Cod Carignan Carmenere Cava certification Chablis Champagne Chardonnay cheese Chenin Blanc Chianti Chile Cinsault cocktails Cognac Colombard Counoise Croatia CSW dessert wine Distill Wars Dona Blanco Falanghina February Fiano formulas France Franciacorta Frankovka Furmint Gamay Garganega Gascony Germany gin Glera Godello Graciano Greece Grenache Grenache Blanc Gros Manseng Gruner Veltliner GSM guest blog Heroes history how to Hungary Israel Italy Japan Kansas kosher Lambrusco Languedoc-Roussillon Lodi Loire love letter Madeira Malbec Marsanne Massachusetts Matchbook Mavrud Mazuelo Mencia Meritage Merlot Mexico mixology Montepulciano Moscato Mourvédre Muscat mythology Nebbiolo Nero d'Avola New York New Zealand news Norello Mascalese Oregon organic original meme Palestine Pecorino Petit Verdot Petite Sirah Petite Verdot photo gallery phylloxera Picpoul Piedmont Pinot Blanc Pinot Gris/Grigio Pinot Meunier Pinot Noir Pinotage Pliny Port Portugal Press Release Primitivo product Prosecco quickie quote recipe retail problems Retsina review Rhone Ribera del Duero Riesling Rioja rose Roussanne Rueda rum Sagrantino Sake Sangiovese Sangria Sauvignon Blanc science Sekt Seyval Blanc Sherry South Africa Spain Sparkling spirits storage study sulfites sustainable SWE Syrah Tannat Tempranillo Tequila Texas Tinta Amarela Torrontes Touriga Nacional Traminer Trebbiano Turkey Tuscany Umbria USA Valdiguié Valpolicella Verdejo Verdicchio Vermentino Vernacca Vidal Blanc video Vinho Verde Viognier Virginia Viura vodka Washington State whiskey White zinfandel wine wine club Wine Pick Zinfandel Zweigelt